I have been playing both of these versions with my son(who is 5yrs old). I love playing two player games with him and he loves "kissing the girls" in Sunset Riders. At first, the SNES version was the only one we liked to play. It just seemed better, but lately, we have been playing the Genesis version a lot. My son seems to think the Genesis version is called "Sunset Riders Two." I guess it is because the guys are bigger or because we played the SNES version first. Either way, both games are great but I can not decide which one I like better. Both seem different from each other and play more like sequals than the same game.

Pros for the Genesis version: Bigger guys, I like how you can shoot the enemies arrows out of the air. I think I read it had more bosses.
Pros for SNES version: I read it plays more like the arcades

Anyways, I can not decide which version I like better. Please exclude the arcade version since I am talking about console versions only. What do you guys think?