What games do you personally think are more common than they are given credit for?
My vote goes to a not necessarily "Classic" game from last gen: Pikmin 2. Everyone says "Rare rare rare!" when it's everywhere. Heck, if you search for "Pikmin 2 rare" on eBay you can find over 10 results for the game. Without the word "rare" it yields over 60. I see it all the time in Gamestop and PnT.