TALLY HO!
Here are the final results based on YOUR votes! The mods deferred to 'public opinion', which seems to be the most fair considering how many people played and voted).
24 Stanley
21 Hiroshi
17 Busters Revenge
13 El Suave
10 Old Man Graves Ghost
10 Rock
9 Random Moogle
8 Adventure Bat
8 Great Mighty POO
8 Guts Man
4 Amazing Paperboy
4 Robotnik
3 Beat up Guile
3 Pick Axe Pete
3 Sothy Jr
2 LarryLaffer
2 Mr. Nutz
2 Nintendo
2 Toadstool
2 SwitchBox
1 1-Up
1 Atari 2600 Pac-Man
1 Hulk
1 Johnny Turbo
1 Parappa
BEFORE I ANNOUNCE THIS OFFICIALLY - if anyone wants to check my math, particularly counting votes for the 1-4 people who are all very close, PLEASE DO!
Tentative congrats in order... as soon as this is announced officially I'll ask you all to reveal yourselves