Originally Posted by
MidnightRider
Yeah, I wanted to mention that I found WWF Wrestlemania Challenge to be decent as well. It really shines in 2 player co-op, as you can innovate with the double teams. Unfortunately you're stuck as the generic characters going through a tournament, but it still works out quite well.
Also, unless you're an importer, as I don't see any other way than emulation to really enjoy this one, The best of the era would easily be Super Fire Pro Wrestling X Premium(which I believe was the one A.C. Sativa was trying to make mention of). An importer would miss out on the ability to hack a save state to be able to leave the ring during a battle royal(not to mention the ability to play it in English), which I think adds a lot to it, but it obviously doesn't function perfectly(the camera sometimes has a hard time trying to follow it, and you could be stuck off screen, trying to fight a guy you can't really see, for a while).
Another great game I don't see mentioned yet is the arcade only WWF Wrestlefest.