What Star Wars game is the best one ever made?

[overengen]

I would like to have your opinion about what Star Wars game you think is the best one ever made. Write the full name of the game and what platform it was made for. Please give a short motivation of your choice!

Thank you for reading my message!

[Mayhem]

TIE Fighter. Took everything good about X-Wing, made it better, allowed you to play as the bad guys and... well it just kicked arse :)

[Phosphor Dot Fossils]

I'm still very partial to Return Of The Jedi: Death Star Battle and The Empire Strikes back on the 2600.

[Sylentwulf]

Empire strikes back on the 2600, or Rogue Squadron on the Gamecube (I hated the difficulty level, but my god, the EXPERIENCE of it all.)

[digdug]

At first I would of said Dark Forces then maybe Jedi Knight, however, after starting to beta test the new Star Wars: Galaxies, One word describes it


WOW

This game is what Star Wars games should be.

Dig Dug

[scooterb23]

Star Wars: The Arcade Game...no not that new Trilogy crap, I'm talking about the old vector game !!!1`

[briskbc]

In my opinion the best games are the vector arcade game, Dark Forces, the SNES trilogy, and Rogue Squadron on the N64. I am starting to lose track of what Star Wars games are coming out. Lucas is just pumping them out.

[zmeston]

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic could've been great, but it's (going to be) awful on virtually every level -- The Phantom Menace of RPGs. Among the lowlights:

1) A subplot directly lifted from "The Trouble With Tribbles" episode of Star Blecch. (Yes, the classic PC game Elite ripped it off too, but I was more forgiving back then.)
2) A very thinly disguised "Tower of Hanoi" puzzle.
3) Reams of interminable dialogue with dozens of interchangably lame characters.
4) Horrendous combat that tries and miserably fails to combine real-time and turn-based systems.
5) Subplots with no real gameplay consequences, just different snatches of interminable dialogue.
6) A very lengthy and incredibly boring subplot that involves a murder trial, and another lengthy/boring subplot that involves a murder investigation. Is this Star Wars or Law and Order?
7) Wretched mini-games, including a very silly take on blackjack, and a racing sequence that makes Super Bombad Racing look like Gran Turismo.

I was already soured on Star Wars before KOTOR; now I actively, openly despise the franchise.

-- Z.

[Raedon]

oldest game, Star wars the arcade game.

Newest game for me was Jedi Knight II.. the single player game was a blast.

[portnoyd]

SNES Trilogy. Far superior to anything so far.

dave

[dreamcaster]

Star Wars: Rogue Leader for GCN. This absolutely blew me away, and really made me feel I was in the Star Wars universe. I can't play this game without going off and watching one of the original trilogy movies, and vice versa.

[Cafeman]

I vote for Rogue Leader: Rogue Squadron II on Gamecube to be considered the best. The way its gameplay and presentation pull you into the original-trilogy universe is only equalled by the original Atari "Star Wars" vector graphics coin-op. Which I'd rate #2.

(_)3

[Ed Oscuro]

At first I would of said Dark Forces then maybe Jedi Knight, however, after starting to beta test the new Star Wars: Galaxies, One word describes it


WOW

This game is what Star Wars games should be.

Games that cost too much to play, and are financially unsound projects for their companies to embark on? My brother followed (I think he still does) the game's progress quite closely, but pay-per-month games are NOT a good idea for a company to get involved with. Call in tech support for a few hours, and right there's your monthly fee.

Now for my personal favorites, I have to say Shadows of the Empire (N64) and Return of the Jedi on the SNES would be my two favorites. If I was a big fan of flying games, I'd mention Rogue Squadron for the N64. With that, I realize my knowledge of Star Wars games is more than a few years out of date, the newest one I've played or even really seen would be Rogue Squadron.

[IGotTheDot]

Super Star Wars for the SNES. The other two where pretty cool, but Super Star Wars was the best in my opinion.

[FrankLee]

Shadows of the Empire (N64) and Starwars: Jedi Starfighter (ps2)

[Arcade Antics]

Atari's original vector arcade game is still the best.

[Captain Wrong]

Star Wars: The Arcade Game...no not that new Trilogy crap, I'm talking about the old vector game !!!1`

If you never got to play it in the sit down cockpit version, you missed out. That game blew me away back in the day. MAME just isn't the same as sitting down and playing with the yoke.

[bargora]

For arcade action, the original Star Wars (sit-down cabinet, of course) rules. For sim-style and multiplayer, I liked X-Wing vs. Tie-Fighter (with the expansion mission pack) for the PC. On consoles, I've only played the Empire Strikes Back and ROTJ Atari 2600 carts, Rogue Squadron (N64) and Starfighter (PS2), of which I like Starfighter best, mainly because it's the most strategic (which isn't saying much in a line-up of console games).

[YoshiM]

On the "classic" side of consoles I really enjoyed Super Empire Strikes Back. Had the right amount of difficulty, great graphics and sound, and was a blast to play. It was the best out of the trilogy, just like the movies :)

On the modern side of consoles it'd be Jedi Knight II: Jedi Outcast. Challenging yet fun and graphically stunning on the Xbox. I didn't play the computer version (which is where the console version was ported from) but it just felt like it was MADE for a console.

Arcade: I have to agree that the original Star Wars was and still is awesome. The Trilogy game is pretty, but it's got that shaft-the-player gameplay where you can't avoid damage at certain points of the game.

[zmeston]

On the modern side of consoles it'd be Jedi Knight II: Jedi Outcast. Challenging yet fun and graphically stunning on the Xbox. I didn't play the computer version (which is where the console version was ported from) but it just felt like it was MADE for a console.

The developers of the Xbox/GCN versions wrote a lengthy article in Game Developer magazine about how much effort they put into console-izing Jedi Knight II; it's one of the most skillfully done PC-to-console ports ever. (Of course, it doesn't hurt that the Xbox is a first cousin of a PC.)

-- Z.

[le geek]

For me, right now it's a tie between the Original Vector Arcade game, and Rogue Squadron for N64. I haven't played Rogue Leader yet though.

The SNES games were just okay IMHO...

Cheers,
Ben

[BenT]

I don't think the well-regarded SNES games have aged well. Going back, I found them *really* rough around the edges, gameplay wise. I used to really like Super Star Wars, but it's pretty average now. Empire, OTOH, (which I didn't play back in the day, but which got bad reviews) seemed *awful*. I totally regret buying it now, and it's in my sell bin.

Considering how that went, I feel no need to check out RotJ.

Anyway, my vote for best SW game goes to the first Dark Forces. While a Doom knock-off, it struck while the iron was still hot and had several technological improvements over id's engine. It was also just well-made and fun. JK's shoddy look and feel totally turned me off.

[Daltone]

TIE Fighter is THE space sim. Simple as.
Oh, and there was an arcade game I played aggees ago (in Rhyl in Wales of all places) which was a full sit down cabinet, had lots of sounds and 'line' (i think ) graphics. That was pretty cool.

[maxlords]

For me, a tie between Jedi Knight 2 and the Star Wars Trilogy Arcade game...that fucking RULED!

[christianscott27]

rouge squadron is the reason i love my N64 and rouge leader is the reason i got my gamecube. i have to say that i still prefer RS to RL, even though the graphics are amazing the control on the N64 is unbeatable. what was really weird is that the rouge squadron people made that phantom menace fighter game with the same engine and its AWFUL!!

as for the classic star wars games i'm kinda partial to ewok adventure.
________
Amateur porn stream (http://www.fucktube.com/)

[dave2236]

Rogue Leader on Gamecube was better than I expected it to be and JKII was very good. BUT The arcade games rock. Any Star Wars arcade game is a blast to play, even that stupid pod racing one wasn't half bad.

[overengen]

Thank you for so many interesting comments!

At the moment I am lost in "The clone wars" (NGC), it is challenging and entertaining but not very hard to finish.
Now I am trying to get my records even better so I may access all bonuses (without cheating that is).
The multiplayer part is not that good, it really needs more variation to become enjoyable and fun to play.
Anyway I am really looking forward to play "Star Wars Rogue Squadron III: Rebel Strike"

I just wonder why no one mentioned "The battle for Naboo".
Is it because it is simply to boring and not worth playing?

So here it goes again...

I would like to have your opinion about what Star Wars game you think is the worst one ever made. Write the full name of the game and what platform it was made for. Please give a short motivation of your choice!

Thank you for reading my message!