Top 50 SNES Games , Alternative Rating System (prototype :p

[hydr0x]

as discussed in this topic:

http://www.digitpress.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=14244

i will try the system that anthony talked of (incl. my "enhancement(?)")

so, send us your top snes lists, up to 50 entries per list, but it don't have to be 50, if u only know of 20, then list only those ;)
the important thing is: they have to be ranked!!!!!! not just best 50 but every game has to have a rank

u may also send a list with games that are listed in this top 50 but u think are not worth being in the list, max 10 games on that list, with a short explanation pls

if u don't want to read the linked topic, it's basically this system: every rank is worth a certain number of points, points of all replies/lists are added together and build the overall list, games listed in your "anti-list" will lose some points ( a fix value, i think 50 points)

so, lets start :)

1. Legend of Zelda, 1600
2. Super Mario Kart, 1450
3. Final Fantasy III, 1240
4. Starwing / Starfox, 1090
5. Tales of Phantasia, 1000
Super Punch-Out, 1000
7. Terranigma, 900
8. Super Robot Wars - Lord Of Elemental (or whatever it's exact name is), 850
9. Super Bomberman 2, 750
10. Seiken Densetsu 3, 700
11. Super Mario World, 650
Actraiser, 650
13. Jimmy Connors Pro Tennis Tour, 600
Pilotwings, 600
15. NBA Jam TE, 550
Space Megaforce, 550
17. Alien 3, 500
SimCity, 500
19. Tiny Toon Adventures, 490
20. Super Mario All-Stars, 480
21. Rock 'n Roll Racing, 470
22. Chrono Trigger, 460
23. Donkey Kong Country, 450
24. Super Mario RPG, 440
25. Lufia 2, 430
26. Super Bomberman 5, 420
27. Super Street Fighter 2 The New Challengers, 410
28. Super Castlevania IV, 400
29. Micro Machines 2, 380
30. ISS Deluxe, 370
31. Super High Impact, 360
32. Super Off-Road, 350
33. Super Probotector / Contra, 340
34. SMW 2: Yoshi's Island, 330
35. Tetris & Dr. Mario, 320
36. Harvest Moon, 310
37. Mega Man X, 300
38. Super Ghouls 'n Ghosts, 290
39. Cybernator, 280
40. Final Fight 2, 270
41. Actraiser 2, 260
42. Magical Quest starring Mickey Mouse, 250
43. FF - Mystic Quest, 240
44. Jurassic Park 2, 230
45. Breath Of Fire 2, 220
46. Super Turrican 2, 210
47. Super Metroid, 200
48. Street Fighter Alpha 2, 180
49. Goof Troop, 170
50. Super R-Type 3, 160

[hydr0x]

i forgot to mention: IMPORTS INCLUDED!!

i think if an import really gets enough points (like terranigma) than it is worth being listed

it would be really nice if u would all help us (just contribute your lists ;) ), so we can test if this system or the "old" system works better

[hydr0x]

come on, it can't be that hard, post you favs even if it's only a top 10 ;)

here my top 50:

1. Tales of Phantasia
2. Terranigma
3. Super Robot Wars - Lord Of Elemental (or whatever it's exact name is)
4. Legend of Zelda
5. Super Mario Kart
6. Seiken Densetsu 3
7. Super Mario World
8. Jimmy Connors Pro Tennis Tour
9. NBA Jam TE
10. Alien 3
11. Tiny Toon Adventures
12. Super Mario All-Stars
13. Rock 'n Roll Racing
14. Chrono Trigger
15. Donkey Kong Country
16. Super Mario RPG
17. Lufia 2
18. Super Bomberman 5
19. Super Street Fighter 2 The New Challengers
20. Super Castlevania IV
21. Final Fantasy 3/6
22. Micro Machines 2
23. ISS Deluxe
24. Super High Impact
25. Super Off-Road
26. Super Probotector / Contra
27. SMW 2: Yoshi's Island
28. Tetris & Dr. Mario
29. Harvest Moon
30. Mega Man X
31. Super Ghouls 'n Ghosts
32. Cybernator
33. Final Fight 2
34. Actraiser 2
35. Magical Quest starring Mickey Mouse
36. FF - Mystic Quest
37. Jurassic Park 2
38. Breath Of Fire 2
39. Super Turrican 2
40. Super Metroid
41. Starwing / Starfox
42. Street Fighter Alpha 2
43. Goof Troop
44. Super R-Type 3
45. Puzzle Bobble / Bust-A-Move
46. Super Tennis
47. Secret Of Mana
48. Secret Of Evermore
49. Final Fight 3
50. TMNT 4 - Turtles in Time

[Anthony1]

I'm working on my list now. But I want to make sure that I make a good list, and not just start randomly thinking of games. I will post my list as soon as I'm done.

Thanks for somebody seeing the value in this ranking system.

[digitalpress]

Here is my "ranked order" of SNES games.

1. Super Punch-Out!!
2. StarFox
3. Final Fantasy III
4. Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
5. Super Bomberman 2
6. Super Mario Kart
7. Actraiser
8. Pilotwings
9. Space Megaforce
10. SimCity