2010 Otto Awards: It is time for nominating

[Oobgarm]

After a 1-year hiatus, it has become that time again. I am going to take nominations for a week's time in order to get data for polls. I will take the top 10 nominees from each category. In the event of a tie, the earlier nominated title gets the spot. This only goes for games released in the year of our Lord 2010. Here are this year's categories:

GOTY (all platforms)
Best Wii Title
Best 360 Title
Best PS3 Title
Best PSP Title
Best DS Title
Best Action Title (FPS, Hack & Slash, Beat Em Up, Fighters and similar)
Best Adventure Title (any action-based title that allows freedom rather than point-to-point)
Best Sports Title
Best Racing Title
Best RPG (turn-based or realtime)
Best Downloadable Title (all platforms)
Biggest Surprise (game titles only please)
Biggest Disappointment (again, game titles only)
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title
Best Graphics (all platforms)
Best Sound & Music (all platforms)

BONUS CATEGORIES:

Best Type of Bacon (Crispy or Chewy)
2010 Punch in the Face (Perkar or GrandAmChandler or Carey85)

Nominate away. Feel free to leave categories blank if you haven't played anything or have no interest in that type of game.

[Oobgarm]

GOTY (all platforms) Super Meat Boy
Best Wii Title Donkey Kong Country Returns
Best 360 Title Super Meat Boy
Best PS3 Title Gran Turismo 5
Best PSP Title Patchwork Heroes
Best DS Title Professor Layton and the Unwound Future
Best Action Title Castlevania: Lords of Shadow
Best Sports Title NCAA Football 11
Best Racing Title Need for Speed: Hot Pursuit
Best Downloadable Title (all platforms) Super Meat Boy
Biggest Surprise (game titles only please) Super Meat Boy
Biggest Disappointment (again, game titles only) Call of Duty: Black Ops
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title Super Meat Boy
Best Graphics (all platforms) Castlevania: Lords of Shadow
Best Sound & Music (all platforms) Super Meat Boy

(I loved Super Meat Boy much, much more than I expected to)

[Frankie_Says_Relax]

GOTY (all platforms): Bayonetta
Best Wii Title: Tatsunoko Vs. Capcom Ultimate All Stars
Best 360 Title: Limbo
Best PS3 Title: God of War III
Best PSP Title: God of War: Ghost of Sparta
Best DS Title: Scribblenauts 2
Best Action Title (FPS, Hack & Slash, Beat Em Up, Fighters and similar): Bayonetta
Best Adventure Title (any action-based title that allows freedom rather than point-to-point): Red Dead Redemption
Best Sports Title: WWE Smackdown Vs. Raw 2011
Best Racing Title: Mod Nation Racers
Best Downloadable Title (all platforms): Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World The Videogame
Biggest Surprise (game titles only please): Dante's Inferno
Biggest Disappointment (again, game titles only): MAG
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title: Mod Nation Racers
Best Graphics (all platforms): God of War III
Best Sound & Music (all platforms): Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World The Videogame

[portnoyd]

I removed all the categories I can't even put a response down for. Not that my game playing was that limited, but most titles that would fit the category are from 2009. Backlog, woo.

GOTY (all platforms): Super Mario Galaxy 2
Best Wii Title: Super Mario Galaxy 2
Best 360 Title: Alan Wake
Best PS3 Title: Heavy Rain
Best DS Title: Ivy The Kiwi
Best Action Title: Dead Rising 2
Best Adventure Title: Bioshock 2
Best Sports Title:
Best Racing Title:
Best RPG:
Best Downloadable Title:
Biggest Surprise: Heavy Rain
Biggest Disappointment: FF13, FF14, 3D Dot Heroes
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title: Heavy Rain
Best Graphics (all platforms): Heavy Rain
Best Sound & Music: God of War III

[Queen Of The Felines]

Deadly Premonition for everything.

[robotriot]

I tried not naming a game twice, except for GOTY of course. I haven't played that many new games this year, I probably missed out on a lot of good ones.

GOTY (all platforms) Mass Effect 2
Best Wii Title: Endless Ocean 2
Best 360 Title: Fable III
Best PS3 Title: Heavy Rain
Best DS Title: Infinite Space
Best Action Title: Red Dead Redemption
Best Adventure Title: Heavy Rain
Best Sports Title: NBA Jam
Best Racing Title: Gran Turismo 5
Best RPG: Mass Effect 2
Best Downloadable Title: Limbo
Biggest Surprise: Apache Air Assault
Biggest Disappointment: Alan Wake
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title: Darkstar One
Best Graphics: Castlevania: Lords of Shadows
Best Sound & Music: Bit. Trip Runner

[Nebagram]

GOTY (all platforms) Super Mario Galaxy 2
Best Wii Title Super Mario Galaxy 2
Best 360 Title Crackdown 2
Best PS3 Title Heavy Rain
Best PSP Title MGS Peace Walker not much competition in this one
Best DS Title DQ IX
Best Action Title (FPS, Hack & Slash, Beat Em Up, Fighters and similar) God of War 3
Best Adventure Title (any action-based title that allows freedom rather than point-to-point) Fallout New Vegas
Best Sports Title N/A
Best Racing Title ModNation
Best RPG (turn-based or realtime) Fallout New Vegas
Best Downloadable Title (all platforms) Pac Man CE DX
Biggest Surprise (game titles only please) Just Cause 2
Biggest Disappointment (again, game titles only) FFXIII
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title Half-Minute Hero
Best Graphics (all platforms) Heavy Rain
Best Sound & Music (all platforms)



Couple of tricky choices in there but for me SMG was unquestionably game of the year. And when I say 'tricky choices' I mean 'gash competition'. Or to put it another way, second on my 'top racing game' for the year would've been Sonic & Sega All Star Racing. Or Super Mario Kart on VC if I were allowed it.

[InsaneDavid]

Didn't play too many "current" releases this year, so lots of blanks for me.

GOTY: N/A
Best Wii Title: N/A
Best 360 Title: N/A
Best PS3 Title: 3D Dot Game Heroes
Best PSP Title: N/A
Best DS Title: Dragon Quest IX
Best Action Title: N/A
Best Adventure Title: 3D Dot Game Heroes
Best Sports Title: N/A
Best Racing Title: Need For Speed Hot Pursuit
Best RPG: Dragon Quest IX
Best Downloadable Title:
Biggest Surprise: Rockband 3
Biggest Disappointment: Super Mario All Stars 25th Anniversary
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title: 3D Dot Game Heroes
Best Graphics: N/A
Best Sound & Music: Super Mario Galaxy 2

[kupomogli]

GOTY Yakuza 3
Best Wii Title n/a
Best 360 Title Red Dead Redemption
Best PS3 Title Yakuza 3
Best PSP Title Ys Oath in Felghana
Best DS Title n/a - Dragon Quest 9 was the only one I've played this year and I was disappointed in it. Lost DS charger afterwards. Haven't played anything since on DS since. Would have liked to play SMT Strange Journey and Lufia but didn't get to either.
Best Action Title Yakuza 3
Best Adventure Title Red Dead Redemption
Best Sports Title n/a
Best Racing Title Split/Second
Best RPG Ys Oath in Felghana
Best Downloadable Title Dead Nation
Biggest Surprise Dante's Inferno
Biggest Disappointment Final Fantasy 13
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title Vanquish
Best Graphics Yakuza 3
Best Sound & Music GTA Episodes From Liberty City

BONUS CATEGORIES:

Best Type of Bacon (Crispy or Chewy) Crispy

*edit*

I forgot about FF13. That's one of the worst RPGs I've ever played, so easily the biggest disappointment this year. I would rather play Eternal Eyes than FF13.

Changed best graphics to Yakuza 3. God of War 3 was a mistake. While God of War has high quality textures, the graphics aren't varied and most of every area is extremely repetitive. Yakuza 3 has slightly worse but still high quality textures yet the areas are all unique and extremely detailed.


Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title Half-Minute Hero

Half Minute Hero came out last year. Amazing game though and definitely definitely is the most overlooked that year.

[Robust]

GOTY Bayonetta
Best Wii Super Mario Galaxy 2
Best 360 Title Bayonetta
Best PS3 Title Bayonetta
Best PSP Title Valkyria Chronicles II
Best DS Title Ivy the Kiwi
Best Action Title Bayonetta
Best Adventure Title
Best Sports Pro Evolution Soccer 2011
Best Racing Title Need For Speed: Hot Pursuit
Best RPG
Best Downloadable Title
Biggest Surprise
Biggest Disappointment
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title Vanquish
Best Graphics Vanquish
Best Sound & Music
BONUS CATEGORIES:

Best Type of Bacon
2010 Punch in the Face

[Chainsaw_Charlie]

GOTY (all platforms) Heavy Rain
Best Wii Title Epic Mickey
Best 360 Title Final Fantasy 13
Best PS3 Title Heavy Rain
Best PSP Title Kingdom Hearts Birth By Sleep
Best DS Title Dragon Quest 9
Best RPG (turn-based or realtime) Shin Megami Tensei STrange Journey

[kupomogli]

Best DS Title Dragon Quest 9
Best RPG (turn-based or realtime) Shin Megami Tensei STrange Journey

I don't get this.

[Chainsaw_Charlie]

I don't get this.

While I thought DQ 9 was the best game for the DS I prefered SMT's story over it

[ubersaurus]

GOTY (all platforms) Mass Effect 2
Best Wii Title Tatsunoko vs. Capcom Ultimate All Stars
Best 360 Title Mass Effect 2
Best DS Title Mario vs. Donkey Kong: Mini Land Mayhem
Best Action Title (FPS, Hack & Slash, Beat Em Up, Fighters and similar) Halo Reach
Best Adventure Title: Dead Rising 2
Best RPG (turn-based or realtime) Mass Effect 2
Best Downloadable Title (all platforms) Super Meat Boy
Biggest Surprise (game titles only please) Death Smiles
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title Death Smiles
Best Graphics (all platforms) Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World
Best Sound & Music (all platforms) Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World

[Kyle15]

GOTY: N/A
Best Wii Title: Sin and Punishment: Successor of The Stars
Best 360 Title: LIMBO
Best PS3 Title: BlazBlue Continuum Shift
Best PSP Title: N/A
Best DS Title: Shin Megami Tensei: Strange Journey
Best Action Title: Bayonetta
Best Adventure Title: Heavy Rain (Does this count? It was an adventure to me!)
Best Sports Title: N/A
Best Racing Title: N/A
Best RPG: Shin Megami Tensei: Strange Journey
Best Downloadable Title: LIMBO
Biggest Surprise: Deadly Premonition
Biggest Disappointment: N/A
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title: Deathsmiles
Best Graphics: BlazBlue Continuum Shift
Best Sound & Music: Heavy Rain

Bacon: CRISPY

[G-Boobie]

GOTY (all platforms): Mass Effect 2
Best Wii Title" Tatsunoko Vs. Capcom Ultimate All Stars
Best 360 Title: Halo: Reach
Best PS3 Title: Heavy Rain
Best PSP Title:
Best DS Title:
Best Action Title: Bayonetta
Best Adventure Title: Assassins Creed: Brotherhood
Best Sports Title: NBA Jam
Best Racing Title:
Best RPG (turn-based or realtime): Mass Effect 2
Best Downloadable Title (all platforms): Super Meat Boy
Biggest Surprise (game titles only please): Amnesia: The Dark Descent
Biggest Disappointment (again, game titles only): Fallout: New Vegas
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title: Deadly Premonition
Best Graphics (all platforms): Stalker: Call of Pripyat
Best Sound & Music (all platforms): Super Meat Boy

Bacon: CRISPY.

[Lady Jaye]

GOTY Mass Effect 2
Best 360 Mass Effect 2
Best DS Dragon Quest 9
Best Action Title (FPS, Hack & Slash, Beat Em Up, Fighters and similar) Mass Effect 2
Best RPG (turn-based or realtime) Dragon Quest 9
Best Downloadable Title (all platforms) Mega Man 10
Biggest Disappointment (again, game titles only) Scott Pilgrim vs. The World

BONUS CATEGORIES:

Best Type of Bacon: Chewy
2010 Punch in the Face: Perkar (sorry, Chris and Carey!)

[GrandAmChandler]

GOTY (all platforms): Halo Reach
Best Wii Title: Donkey Kong Country Returns
Best 360 Title: Halo Reach
Best PS3 Title: God of War III
Best PSP Title: God Of War: Ghost Of Sparta
Best DS Title: Picross 3D
Best Action Title (FPS, Hack & Slash, Beat Em Up, Fighters and similar): Halo Reach
Best Adventure Title (any action-based title that allows freedom rather than point-to-point) 3D Dot Game Heroes
Best Sports Title: NBA JAM
Best Racing Title: Mod Nation Racers
Best RPG (turn-based or realtime): Dragon Quest XI
Best Downloadable Title (all platforms): Super Meat Boy
Biggest Surprise (game titles only please): Super Meat Boy
Biggest Disappointment (again, game titles only): Final Fantasy XIII
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title: Picross 3D
Best Graphics (all platforms): Kirby's Epic Yarn
Best Sound & Music (all platforms): Scott Pilgrim vs. The World

BONUS CATEGORIES:

Best Type of Bacon (Crispy or Chewy): CRISPY, but not burnt.
2010 Punch in the Face (Perkar or GrandAmChandler or Carey85) Definitely Carey85.

[frogofdeath]

GOTY (all platforms) Picross 3D
Best Wii Title Goldeneye 007
Best 360 Title Red Dead Redemption
Best DS Title Picross 3D
Best Adventure Title (any action-based title that allows freedom rather than point-to-point) Red Dead Redemption
Biggest Surprise (game titles only please) Goldeneye 007
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title Picross 3D

BONUS CATEGORIES:

Best Type of Bacon Crispy, almost burnt

[Voliko]

GOTY (all platforms) - Super Mario Galaxy 2
Best Wii - Title Super Mario Galaxy 2
Best 360 - Title Mass Effect 2
Best PS3 - Title God of War III
Best DS - Title Dragon Quest IX
Best Adventure Title - Red Dead Redemption
Best Sports Title - NBA Jam
Best RPG - Dragon Quest IX
Biggest Disappointment - Final Fantasy XIII
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title - NIER
Best Sound/Music - NIER

Bacon - Always TENDER

[hbkprm]

alpha protocol for best rpg, (tied with deadly premonition) most overlooked and game of the year (tied with lost planet 2)
goldeneye (also get tied for biggest surprise with final fantasy xiv), dkc returns (tied together) for best wii
bayonetta for best action
yakuza 3 for best ps3
deadly primonition for best 360 and most overlooked (tied with alpha protocol)
lost planet 2 (tied with alpha protocol for goty), medal of honor (tied together)(medal of honor ties for best graphics with just cause 2) for best action
just cause 2 (tied with metal of honor for best graphics) for best adventure
final fantasy xiii for best music and sound

[SpaceHarrier]

GOTY (all platforms) Super Mario Galaxy 2
Best Wii Title Super Mario Galaxy 2
Best 360 Title Pac-Man CE DX
Best PS3 Title God of War III
Best PSP Title Persona 3
Best DS Title Pokemon Gold/Silver
Best Action Title God of War III
Best Adventure Title Red Dead Redemption
Best Sports Title NBA Jam
Best Racing Title F1 2010
Best RPG Title Persona 3 PSP
Best Downloadable Title (all platforms) Afterburner Climax
Biggest Surprise (game titles only please) Scott Pilgrim vs. The World (the game)
Biggest Disappointment (again, game titles only) Gran Turismo 5
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title Metroid: Other M
Best Graphics (all platforms) God of War III
Best Sound & Music (all platforms) Super Street Fighter IV

Best Type of Bacon: Chewy
2010 Punch in the Face: GrandAmChandler, not because I have anything against him, just solely based on the fact that I never cared for the TV show 'Friends' and found Chandler extremely annoying although Chandler from Suikoden was pretty cool it still doesn't make up for it, not by a long shot.

[Icarus Moonsight]

Best Sound & Music (all): Korg DS-10 Plus (individual results vary)

Best Bacon: Griddle-pressed, crispy and AYCE

Rest of the categories I either agree with what's been nom'd already or I have collected insufficient data/experience.

VANQUISH!

[eskobar]

This is my list

GOTY (all platforms) : Heavy Rain
Best Wii Title: Super Mario Galaxy 2
Best 360 Title: Mass Effect 2
Best PS3 Title: Heavy Rain
Best PSP Title: Valkyria Chronicles II
Best DS Title: Infinite Space
Best Action Title (FPS, Hack & Slash, Beat Em Up, Fighters and similar): Yakuza 3
Best Adventure Title (any action-based title that allows freedom rather than point-to-point): Red Dead Redemption
Best Sports Title: Pro Evo Soccer 2011
Best Racing Title: Gran Turismo 5
Best RPG (turn-based or realtime): Infinite Space
Best Downloadable Title (all platforms) : Joe Danger
Biggest Surprise (game titles only please) : 3d dot heroes
Biggest Disappointment (again, game titles only): Final Fantasy XIII
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title : White Knight Chronicles
Best Graphics (all platforms): Heavy Rain
Best Sound & Music (all platforms) : Heavy Rain

BONUS CATEGORIES:

Best Type of Bacon (Crispy or Chewy) Chewy
2010 Punch in the Face (Perkar or GrandAmChandler or Carey85) GrandAmChandler

[NayusDante]

I haven't played all that much this year, I'm still way behind in my backlog. Hopefully I'll be more in-the-moment in 2011.

GOTY - N/A
Best Wii Title - Metroid Other M
Best 360 Title - N/A
Best PS3 Title - N/A
Best PSP Title - N/A
Best DS Title - N/A
Best Action Title - Metroid Other M
Best Adventure Title - N/A
Best Sports Title - N/A
Best Racing Title - Gran Turismo 5
Best RPG - N/A
Best Downloadable Title - Super Meat Boy
Biggest Surprise - Mega Man Zero Collection
Biggest Disappointment - Final Fantasy XIII
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title - Final Fantasy XIV (It'll get better... >_<)
Best Graphics - Final Fantasy XIII
Best Sound & Music (all platforms) - Mega Man 10

[Cryomancer]

GOTY Dead Rising 2
Best Wii Title: No More Heroes 2: Desperate Struggle
Best 360 Title: Dead Rising 2
Best PS3 Title: n/a
Best PSP Title: Z.H.P. Unlosing Ranger VS. Darkdeath Evilman
Best DS Title: Dragon Quest XI
Best Action Title: Dead Rising 2
Best Adventure Title: Just Cause 2
Best Sports Title: n/a
Best Racing Title: Sonic & Sega All-Stars Racing
Best RPG: Shin Megami Tensei: Strange Journey
Best Downloadable Title: Comic Jumper
Biggest Surprise: Sonic & Sega All-Stars Racing
Biggest Disappointment: Red Dead Redemption
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title: Matt Hazard: Blood Bath and Beyond
Best Graphics: Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World
Best Sound & Music: No More Heroes 2: Desperate Struggle

[Gooch3008]

GOTY Amnesia: The Dark Descent
Best Wii Title Sin & Punishment
Best 360 Title NO
Best PS3 Title GT5
Best PSP Title
Best DS Title NO
Best Action Title
Best Adventure Title
Best Sports Title NO
Best Racing Title GT5
Best RPG (turn-based or realtime) NO
Best Downloadable Title (all platforms) Amnesia: The Dark Descent
Biggest Surprise Amnesia: The Dark Descent
Biggest Disappointment (again, game titles only)
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title Amnesia: The Dark Descent
Best Graphics Castlevania: Lords of Shadow
Best Sound & Music (all platforms) Amnesia: The Dark Descent

[Gooch3008]

Anyone not at least mentioning Amnesia in their post are wrong.

[keldon]

GOTY (all platforms): Fable III
Best Wii Title: Kirby's Epic Yarn
Best 360 Title: Fable III
Best PS3 Title: ModNation Racers
Best PSP Title: Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3
Best DS Title: Golden Sun: Dark Dawn
Best Action Title (FPS, Hack & Slash, Beat Em Up, Fighters and similar): Splatterhouse
Best Adventure Title (any action-based title that allows freedom rather than point-to-point): Red Dead Redemption
Best Sports Title: NHL 11
Best Racing Title: Need for Speed:Hot Pursuit
Best RPG (turn-based or realtime): Golden Sun: Dark Dawn (DS)
Best Downloadable Title (all platforms): Super Meat Boy
Biggest Surprise (game titles only please): Super Meat Boy
Biggest Disappointment (again, game titles only): Sonic Colors
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title: 3D Dot Game Heroes
Best Graphics (all platforms): Gran Turismo 5
Best Sound & Music (all platforms): Red Dead Redemption

[Richter Belmount]

Best Xbox 360 game : Sonic Free Riders
Best Ps3 game : Heavy Rain
Game of the year: MINECRAFT
Biggest disappointment : Mass Effect 2 , final fantasy 14 , Super Mario Galaxy 2

[Gamemaster_ca_2003]

GOTY (all platforms): Red Dead Redemption
Best Wii Title: Goldeneye 007
Best 360 Title: Red Dead Redemption
Best PS3 Title: God of War III
Best PSP Title: Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3 Portable
Best DS Title: Picross 3D
Best Action Title: God of War III
Best Adventure Title: Red Dead Redemption
Best Sports Title: NBA JAM
Best Racing Title: Need For Speed: Hot Pursuit
Best RPG: Mass Effect 2
Best Downloadable Title: Pac-Man CE DX
Biggest Surprise: Apache Air Assault
Biggest Disappointment: Final Fantasy 14
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title: VVVVVV
Best Graphics: Final Fantasy 14
Best Sound & Music: Rock Band 3

[LeGIt]

GOTY: Borderlands (PS3) also includes Duke Nukem Forever beta access code :P
Best Wii Title: ???
Best 360 Title: ???
Best PS3 Title: Transformers: War for Cybertron (The deathmatch is AWESOME!)
Best PSP Title: Phantasy Star Portable 2
Best DS Title: ???
Best Action Title: Army of Two: 40th Day on PS3 (storyline co-op)
Best Adventure Title: Dead Rising 2 (albeit took a while to get into)
Best Sports Title: ???
Best Racing Title: ???
Best RPG: ???
Best Downloadable Title: Pixeljunk Racers 2nd Lap (PlayStation Network Store/PS3)
Biggest Surprise: ???
Biggest Disappointment: Call of Duty: Black Ops
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title: Battlefied: Bad Company 2
Best Graphics: ???
Best Sound & Music: ???

[Fuyukaze]

GOTY (all platforms)--Nier
Best Wii Title--Fragile Dreams
Best 360 Title--Nier
Best PS3 Title--Nier
Best PSP Title--Ys Seven
Best DS Title--Dragon Quest IX
Best Action Title (FPS, Hack & Slash, Beat Em Up, Fighters and similar)--3D Dot Game Heroes
Best Adventure Title (any action-based title that allows freedom rather than point-to-point)--Enslaved
Best Sports Title--N/A
Best Racing Title--Blur
Best RPG (turn-based or realtime)--Etrian Oddysey III
Best Downloadable Title (all platforms)--N/A
Biggest Surprise (game titles only please)--Nier
Biggest Disappointment (again, game titles only)--Resident Evil 5 (gold edition)
Most Overlooked/Under Appreciated Title--Nier
Best Graphics (all platforms)--3D Dot Game Heroes
Best Sound & Music (all platforms)--Nier

Best Type of Bacon (Crispy or Chewy)--Crispy, always.
2010 Punch in the Face (Perkar or GrandAmChandler or Carey85)--GAC. Day 8 man, day 8. That's all I can say.

[YoshiM]

By the way it looks, I didn't play a ton of 2010 games last year. I too had a back log of 2009 games.

GOTY (all platforms):Alan Wake
Best Wii Title: Goldeneye 007
Best 360 Title: Alan Wake
Best Action Title: Bioshock 2
Best Adventure Title: Alan Wake
Best Downloadable Title (all platforms): Pac-Man Championship Edition DX
Biggest Surprise (game titles only please): Alan Wake
Biggest Disappointment (again, game titles only): Medal of Honor
Best Graphics (all platforms): Alan Wake
Best Sound & Music (all platforms): Alan Wake

BONUS CATEGORIES:

Best Type of Bacon (Crispy or Chewy): Chewy...ie "soggy"

Dang...seems like I've got a gaming stiffy for Alan Wake. Bought the collector's edition on the cheap and just fell in love with it. Even choked me up a bit near the end. Loved the book that was included.