PDA

View Full Version : REVIEW: Atari Anthology (PS2)



Flack
11-22-2004, 01:22 PM
Like millions of other 30-year-olds, I grew up with an Atari 2600 in my living room. And, like many other veteran gamers, I still love the little thing. I and many others like me spent time each week searching thrift stores, flea markets, and pawn shops for trinkets of my past. A joystick here, a game cartridge there ... it's like being in a world-wide videogame treasure hunt.

But maybe you're not that guy. Maybe you had an Atari 2600 as a kid and outgrew it. Maybe you're nostalgic and just want to sit down and play a few of those games again, without going through the hassle of finding a working 2600 and getting a piece of old hardware to work with your new television. Or maybe you're a younger gamer, and want to find out what all the fuss was about two little white paddles and a square ball bouncing back and forth between them. If you're interested enough in Atari games to fork out some cash but don't see it as a lasting hobby, then Atari Anthology for the PS2 and Xbox is probably for you.

Atari Anthology contains 80+ games. About 60 of those are direct ports of original 2600 games. The remaining 20 or so titles are actual arcade games. Note that the word Atari in the title has a double meaning -- not only are the games FOR the Atari system, but these are all games BY Atari as well. You'll find no Activision, Parker Brothers or Colecovision games within.

The "stellar" menu system (because it deals with outer space, not necessarily because it's terrific) divides the games up into nine categories. Classic video games take up one of the choices; the other eight are categories of Atari 2600 games (adventure games, sports games, etc). The categories make finding games easier, and is a better solution than forcing players to scroll through a lengthy list. The menu system is reminiscent of the Star Wars DVD menus, where each genre of games is apparently stored in a different solar system and every selection has you whisking around the galaxy. While easy enough to navigate, the spinning of and zooming through constellations gets old pretty quickly. The nine categories are as follows:

Adventure Games contains some of the earliest graphical RPGs around, including Adventure, Haunted House, and all three Swordquest games.

Action Games contains many of the systems most recognizable games, including Outlaw, Flag Capture, Circus Atari and the system's launch title, Combat.

Arcade Originals contains several actual videogames, including Asteroids, Centipede, Tempest, and Missile Command. There are also several lesser known titles, such as Liberator, Red Baron, and Black Widow.

Arcade at Home contains several arcade games which were ported to the Atari 2600. Here you'll find the home version of games like Asteroids, Centipede, Video Pinball, Breakout and more.

Mind Games houses several of the console's more strategic titles, including 3D Tic-Tac-Toe, Video Chess, and Surround (which predates TRON's Light Cycles by several years).

Sports Games includes all the classic man-to-man titles, including bowling, football, baseball, and even golf.

Racing Games include Night Driver, Slot Racers, Sprintmaster, Steeplechase, and Street Racer. This is one area in particular that reminded me how many good 3rd party titles there were for the 2600.

Space Games contains games like Space War, Star Raiders, Star Ship and the classic Yars' Revenge.

The final category, Casino Games, includes Blackjack, Casino, and Slot Machine.

Each game contains bonus material, beginning with scans of the manuals, boxes, and cartridges themselves. More experienced players will be able to unlock additional bonus materials, including FMV videos.

The games also include different variations for additional replay value. These include a trippy mode (where everything color cycles and leaves tracers), time challenge, time warp (in which the game's clock cycles randomly speed up and slow down), hot seat (a strange mode where your game is interrupted every few seconds with a different game!), and double speed. Maybe it's just me, but I didn't really see any of these as being lasting features I would use later on down the road. In fact, I found most of them annoying very quickly. One thing I didn't find annoying was the included descriptions on the menu of each games' choices. Atari 2600 games often came with several different difficultly level settings. Back then, the only way to know which did what was to refer to the manual. Atari Anthology fortunately spares us that paper hunt, and shows what each variation does right on the menu screen.

Atari Anthology's game selection appears to draw heavily from the system's early titles. Many of the later games in Atari's library for one reason or another simply aren't here. Games like Moon Patrol, Galaxian, Berzerk, Joust, and even Pac-Man are all superior to many of the games that appear here.

Another problem veteran gamers will notice are the controls. Try as they might, no joystick (analog or digital) will ever replace paddles. Period. Circus Atari, Breakout, and Warlords are difficult if not impossible to play with a joystick.

There were two major problems I encountered with this title. One was the difficulty in reading some of the text, particularly in the emulated arcade games. I won't bag on the title too hard because (A) you can play them without reading it, and (B) I'm using a projector so maybe something it getting lost in the translation, but it still looked pretty weak. The other problem I encountered was within some of the games itself. I'll use Asteroids (2600) as an example. In the two minutes I played, I flew directly through an asteroid not once but twice. Another time, I blew up when I was close, but had not yet touched, an asteroid. I hate to base a review on the old "where there's smoke there's fire" addage, but it did make me wonder if bugs had crept into other games on the disc as well.

Also of note is the fact that the arcade games, by default, appear "zoomed out" and inside a simulated arcade bezel. You'll have to dig through menu screens to find out how to zoom in and where to disable them should you want to play these games full screen.

Bottom line, is it worth the $19.95 asking price? You bet, especially for those who don't still own an Atari 2600. With the recent interest in retro gaming, an Atari 2600 itself could run you more than this title costs, and that's without the games.

Complete Game Listing

Classic arcade hits:

Asteroids
Asteroids Deluxe
Battlezone
Atari Black Widow
Centipede
Crystal Castles
Gravitar
Liberator
Lunar Lander
Major Havoc
Millipede
Missile Command
Pong
Atari Red Baron
Super Breakout
Atari Space Duel
Tempest
Warlords

Atari 2600 titles:

Atari 3D Tic-Tac-Toe
Atari Adventure
Atari Air•Sea Battle
Asteroids
Atari Video Cube
Backgammon
Battlezone
Blackjack
Bowling
Breakout
Canyon Bomber
Casino
Centipede
Circus Atari
Combat
Crystal Castles
Demons to Diamonds
Desert Falcon
Dodge ’Em
Double Dunk
Flag Capture
Football
Fun With Numbers
Golf
Gravitar
Hangman
Haunted House
Home Run
Human Cannonball
Atari Math Gran Prix
Atari Maze Craze
Millipede
Miniature Golf
Missile Command
Atari Night Driver
Off the Wall
Atari Outlaw
Quadrun
Radar Lock
Realsports Baseball
Realsports Football
Realsports Tennis
Realsports Volleyball
Sky Diver
Slot Machine
Atari Slot Racers
Atari Space War
Sprintmaster
Star Raiders
Atari Star Ship
Steeplechase
Stellar Track
Atari Street Racer
Atari Submarine Commander
Atari Super Baseball
Super Breakout
Atari Super Football
Atari Surround
Swordquest: Earthworld
Swordquest: Fireworld
Swordquest: Waterworld
Video Checkers
Video Chess
Video Olympics
Video Pinball
Yars’ Revenge

NE146
11-22-2004, 01:32 PM
Nice review :)


There were two major problems I encountered with this title. One was the difficulty in reading some of the text, particularly in the emulated arcade games. I won't bag on the title too hard because (A) you can play them without reading it, and (B) I'm using a projector so maybe something it getting lost in the translation, but it still looked pretty weak

You didn't mention if you tried turning off the arcade bezel artwork (which is on by default) and zooming in full? That's pretty much the only way to play the arcade ports as they're just too tiny to see anything in their default mode @_@

Kejoriv
11-22-2004, 01:39 PM
Yea, I think Im gonna have to ask Santa to get me this game. I think its definitely worth the money.

digitalpress
11-22-2004, 01:43 PM
Nice review, Flack!

This one is on my Christmas list. I don't usually jump on these compilations because a) I still have my Atari 2600 near my TV - it's modded so my picture is at least as good as what I'm going to see on my Xbox. b) the arcade games I play regularly on MAME with the HotRod SE twin arcade stick, high-quality speakers and monitor - again, I'm not really getting anything with the compilation disc.

But, like any music fan who would buy the "greatest hits" album of their favorite band despite the fact that they own all of those songs already, I'll buy just about anything with "Atari 2600" attached to it - or the old Atari, for that matter.

Flack
11-22-2004, 01:57 PM
You didn't mention if you tried turning off the arcade bezel artwork (which is on by default) and zooming in full? That's pretty much the only way to play the arcade ports as they're just too tiny to see anything in their default mode @_@

You know what, I had a note about that jotted down and I think it got discarded. I edited it back in, as I think that's worth mentioning. The zoom in/out feature is right up front but you have to dig a little deeper to find the bezel thing. Strange option indeed.

zmweasel
11-22-2004, 02:07 PM
Atari Anthology's game selection appears to draw heavily from the system's early titles. Many of the later games in Atari's library for one reason or another simply aren't here. Games like Moon Patrol, Galaxian, Berzerk, Joust, and even Pac-Man are all superior to many of the games that appear here.

Anthology doesn't include any movie tie-ins or licensed coin-ops, hence the absence of Superman, Raiders of the Lost Ark, E.T., Berzerk, et cetera.

-- Z.

Sniderman
11-22-2004, 03:00 PM
Hmmm... I'm torn. I have an Atari 2600 with most - if not all - of the 2600 games all ready. And I'd rather play 'em on the original equipment with a blister-inducing rubber joystick. I enjoyed Activision Anthology when it came out, but the same holds true. I like a joystick in my hand. :D

(perverts)

That said, I'm pretty impressed with the arcade line up. ESPECIALLY Red Baron and Major Havok. Two most excellent games, never seen before on the home consoles. If only there were more of these to push me over the edge. (Battlezone's been done before, I have Tempest X3, Asteroids, etc.) Might make a good Xmas gift for me, but I'll probably pass on a purchase.

Kamino
11-22-2004, 03:02 PM
Hmmm... I'm torn. I have an Atari 2600 with most - if not all - of the 2600 games all ready. And I'd rather play 'em on the original equipment with a blister-inducing rubber joystick. I enjoyed Activision Anthology when it came out, but the same holds true. I like a joystick in my hand. :D

(perverts)

That said, I'm pretty impressed with the arcade line up. ESPECIALLY Red Baron and Major Havok. Two most excellent games, never seen before on the home consoles. If only there were more of these to push me over the edge. (Battlezone's been done before, I have Tempest X3, Asteroids, etc.) Might make a good Xmas gift for me, but I'll probably pass on a purchase.

Being able to play quadrun is worth the price of admission alone.
If only obelix was also on here, it'dbe sold. (Last I checked, obelix IS an ATARI release, yes?)

NE146
11-22-2004, 03:05 PM
(Battlezone's been done before, I have Tempest X3, Asteroids, etc.)

It's worth noting the extra options those games have that you may not be aware of..

Battlezone has the option of having "color vectors".. so imagine Battlezone with color vectors like Tempest and you get the idea. Tempest has the option of playing Tempest Tubes instead of the original. Asteroids has a background option as well which makes it look somewhat nicer. There are various examples of this kind of treatment for each game.

All games also have the "trippy" option where they leave tracers. They also have a double speed option if you're insane. Also.. there seems to be a mode where it randomly jumps from one game to another, so you can be playing Asteroids for 1 minute.. then all of a sudden, you're in Battlezone land! Kinda kooky :)

Sniderman
11-22-2004, 03:36 PM
If only obelix was also on here, it'dbe sold. (Last I checked, obelix IS an ATARI release, yes?) Yup, but it's a licensed character from Hachette, who has replaced Dargaud, so no chance there.

But, funny you should mention Obelix, pal of Asterix. I saw this game (http://www.gamespot.com/ps2/action/asterixobelix/) at EB just yesterday. Characters aren't nearly as well-known in the States as they are in Europe, so it was a surprise to see them starring in a NSTC release.

Lady Jaye
11-22-2004, 04:02 PM
Hachette? Since when is Hachette holding the rights to Asterix??? It used to be Dargaud until the co-creator of the series, Albert Uderzo, created his own publishing house called Les éditions Albert-René (René being in reference to the great, late René Goscinny, who penned the Asterix and Lucky Luke series, among countless others, until his untimely death in 1977).

I just did a bit of research and it turns out that Uderzo lost the rights to the earlier books (from 1959 to 1984) and that the rights were later sold from Dargaud to Hachette.

Nevertheless, where videogames are concerned, I believe that it is Les Éditions Albert-René that must accept licensing offers, not Hachette, since we're talking new material here (videogames).

Flack
11-22-2004, 04:34 PM
(Battlezone's been done before, I have Tempest X3, Asteroids, etc.)

It's worth noting the extra options those games have that you may not be aware of..

Battlezone has the option of having "color vectors".. so imagine Battlezone with color vectors like Tempest and you get the idea. Tempest has the option of playing Tempest Tubes instead of the original. Asteroids has a background option as well which makes it look somewhat nicer. There are various examples of this kind of treatment for each game.

All games also have the "trippy" option where they leave tracers. They also have a double speed option if you're insane. Also.. there seems to be a mode where it randomly jumps from one game to another, so you can be playing Asteroids for 1 minute.. then all of a sudden, you're in Battlezone land! Kinda kooky :)

I just barely touched on the game options, but I do kind of stick by what I said in that most of them were annoying. The "random game jumping" mode is like trying to watch a television show with someone else flipping channels with the remote while you're trying to watch. I played the tracer mode with Asteroids and Centipede, which effectively made both unplayable for me. Maybe someone else will find those features more enjoyable than I did. I couldn't stand them. The most annoying one was the speed cycle one, where the game is continually speeding up and slowing down.

I think the $20 price mark is certainly worth it, more so if you're a guy (or gal!) who isn't into MAME. It's certainly more convenient for the average person to throw a disc into their PS2 over hooking up an Atari 2600 and hunting down all those games. Of course, as we all know, Digital Press isn't made up of "average people", so we may not be the specific market this game is being marketed to.

DaBargainHunta
11-22-2004, 04:36 PM
Fantastic review, Flack. I definitely want to pick this one up ASAP. Yeah, I still have my old 2600 (though not with a lot of the games on this disc), and I could probably hunt down roms of most of these, but I prefer the convenience of having them all on one disc - with the manuals, box art, AND cartridge art to boot. I guess could probably hunt down scans of all of the above online, but who has that kind of time? :) Time is money, so it's a no-brainer to pay $20 and have all that work done for me. :D

kainemaxwell
11-22-2004, 04:37 PM
Great review, I'm sold (mostly for the fact that I can finally play Adventure and play Yar's Revenge again).

blissfulnoise
11-22-2004, 04:37 PM
It's probably worth noting that the Xbox version supports 1080i which is quite interesting.

Lady Jaye
11-22-2004, 04:51 PM
Is it just me, or the trippy version described by Flack pretty much sounds like the color cycle that you have on the 2600 when you leave it on, untouched, when not playing (whose purpose was to avoid screen burns)?

Flack
11-22-2004, 05:12 PM
Is it just me, or the trippy version described by Flack pretty much sounds like the color cycle that you have on the 2600 when you leave it on, untouched, when not playing (whose purpose was to avoid screen burns)?

Oh no, it's not like that. It's much smoother, and much more intense. It doesn't "flash", it kind of "flows", if that makes sense.

john_soper
11-22-2004, 05:20 PM
Whoo-hoo Star Ship, Space War and all three Swordquest games. They really brought out the heavy hitters :)

SoulBlazer
11-22-2004, 05:45 PM
I agree, I hear the XBox version is the better of the two.

Djfinny
11-22-2004, 05:58 PM
It's probably worth noting that the Xbox version supports 1080i which is quite interesting.



SOLD! I gotta see Atari games on my Sony 34" XBR HDTV! :D

DJ

Captain Wrong
11-23-2004, 02:46 AM
I know I'm late, but nice review!

I'm kinda with Snider though...I guess I'm a bit of a purist.

bargora
11-23-2004, 11:53 AM
I concede that original equipment is the way to go, but it's going to be a hell of a lot easier to take that disc with me when I visit my brother for Thanksgiving than it would be to pack up the whole kit and kaboodle.

DigitalSpace
11-23-2004, 12:01 PM
Nice review! I'll probably get the PS2 version of this soon, unless I get an XBox first.

NE146
11-23-2004, 12:06 PM
I'm kinda with Snider though...I guess I'm a bit of a purist.

Actually I think you're more with 98% of this board! LOL

I mean, obviously you're kind of preaching to the choir... This is the DP boards not the Gamefaqs forum ;)

Flack
11-23-2004, 01:19 PM
That's true. To play Atari Anthology I actually had to move my 2600 out of the way. Talk about irony.

goatdan
11-23-2004, 01:22 PM
Does Anthology save high scores?

Flojomojo
11-24-2004, 09:17 AM
Does Anthology save high scores?For the arcade games, it not only saves your scores, it also automatically posts your highest to the XBOX Live scoreboard if you're connected (signs you in by default if you want). Nice.

s1lence
11-26-2004, 11:49 AM
Hmmm... I'm torn. I have an Atari 2600 with most - if not all - of the 2600 games all ready. And I'd rather play 'em on the original equipment with a blister-inducing rubber joystick.

So true, I had a guy at a restaurant comment on my Atari tshirt about how he got one of those Atari Controller game things and how cool it was. My responce was that its better on the real thing.

kainemaxwell
11-26-2004, 12:37 PM
I've yet to see this in stores.

Lady Jaye
11-26-2004, 12:43 PM
Can the hi-scores also be posted online via the PS2?

bargora
11-29-2004, 08:02 PM
So I picked up the Xbox version for my brother. He connects his Xbox to a wide screen TV through component cables via some intermediate electronics boxes (beats me what all that newfangled stuff is). The upshot is that the picture would not display. Sound, yes. Picture, no. Everything worked fine when he connected through S-video. Other games worked fine over the component connection, and the Xbox worked fine (showing the initial outrageously cool logo) up until you got into the part where the disc takes over the display settings.

Anybody else have any trouble getting Atari Anthology (Xbox) to display over component cables?