Robot War Continues [Wired.com]
Where is Arthur C. Clarke when you need him? Are the killer robots coming, or aren't they?
Last week's post, where I dismissed calls to ban 'imaginary' killing machines, sparked a healthy debate, including a drop-in from Noel Sharkey, a roboticist who has advocated banning killer robots. He writes in the comment section:
"I approve of Sharon's take on robot scare stories of the past from academics who have read too much science fiction. But in this case we are talking about near-future science fact."
My point, which I'll state here more clearly, is that rather than debating the real issue -- what are the proper limits on the autonomous operations of weapons? -- we are debating something a tad fantastical, an army of self-directing, lethal machines, deciding when they should kill or not. Terminators, in other words. I realize that debating Terminators is more fun, because it provides such sexy headlines as "Automated killer robots 'threat to humanity,'" but I'm not sure it really addresses the main issue.
MORE...
Reply With Quote
