I listed several video game related items on ebay recently. One of my buyers who won 5 auctions for a total of about $75, claims he bid on one of the items that he won (for about $15) by mistake and doesn't want the item. He has offered to pay all ebay fees related to listing and selling the item.

How does one "accidently" bid on something on ebay?

My first reaction is to tell the guy "hell no, suck it up, pay for ALL the items you won and put it back up on ebay yourself if you don't want it" -- but I'm trying to be fair and reasonable.

Anyone else have a similar situation or any advice seller to seller? What is fair here?

Kevin