This is a listing of all the covers of EGM (last updated: 03/10/2009 with some minor changes). I have now, finally, finished collecting data for all of the issues published. Now to finish up my Gamepro issues.
1989
[ ] EGM 000 (Feb 1989): 1989 Buyers Guide (Castlevania 2/Predator/Thunder Blade)
[ ] EGM 001 (May/Jun 1989): Mega Man 2
[ ] EGM 002 (Jul/Aug 1989): 16-bit Gaming
[ ] EGM 003 (Sep/Oct 1989): Ironsword: Wizards & Warriors II
[ ] EGM 004 (Nov 1989): Ghouls n' Ghosts
[ ] EGM 005 (Dec 1989): 1990 Buyers Guide
1990s
1990
[ ] EGM 006 (Jan 1990): Batman
[ ] EGM 007 (Feb 1990): Alien Syndrom
[ ] EGM 008 (Mar 1990): TurboGrafx-16 vs. Genesis
[ ] EGM 009 (Apr 1990): Castlevania III
[ ] EGM 010 (May 1990): Super C
[ ] EGM 011 (Jun 1990): The Mafat Conspiracy
[ ] EGM 012 (Jul 1990): Ninja Gaiden 2
[ ] EGM 013 (Aug 1990): Strider
[ ] EGM 014 (Sep 1990): Mega Man 3
[ ] EGM 015 (Oct 1990): 1991 Video Game Buyer's Guide
[ ] EGM 016 (Nov 1990): Super Mario World
[ ] EGM 017 (Dec 1990): The Simpsons
1991
[ ] EGM 018 (Jan 1991): G.I. Joe
[ ] EGM 019 (Feb 1991): Bonk's Revenge
[ ] EGM 020 (Mar 1991): Battletoads
[ ] EGM 021 (Apr 1991): Cyberball
[ ] EGM 022 (May 1991): Sonic the Hedgehog
[ ] EGM 023 (Jun 1991): Hudson Hawk
[ ] EGM 024 (Jul 1991): T2: Judgement Day
[ ] EGM 025 (Aug 1991): Super NES Buyer's Guide
[ ] EGM 026 (Sep 1991): Sega CD Preview
[ ] EGM 027 (Oct 1991): Super Mario World
[ ] EGM 028 (Nov 1991): Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 3
[ ] EGM 029 (Dec 1991): The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
1992
[ ] EGM 030 (Jan 1992): Star Trek
[ ] EGM 031 (Feb 1992): Street Fighter 2
[ ] EGM 032 (Mar 1992): 1992 Video Game Preview
[ ] EGM 033 (Apr 1992): Street Fighter 2
[ ] EGM 034 (May 1992): Super Double Dragon
[ ] EGM 035 (Jun 1992): Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 4
[ ] EGM 036 (Jul 1992): Batman Returns
[ ] EGM 037 (Aug 1992): Sonic the Hedgehog 2
[ ] EGM 038 (Sep 1992): 1992 Fall Preview (Ren & Stimpy, Sonic 2, Street Fighter 2)
[ ] EGM 039 (Oct 1992): Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (Genesis)
[ ] EGM 040 (Nov 1992): Super Star Wars
[ ] EGM 041 (Dec 1992): Road Rash II
1993
[ ] EGM 042 (Jan 1993): Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: The Hyperstone Heist
[ ] EGM 043 (Feb 1993): Bubsy
[ ] EGM 044 (Mar 1993): Star Fox
[ ] EGM 045 (Apr 1993): Bram Stoker's Dracula
[ ] EGM 046 (May 1993): Street Fighter II: Championship Edition
[ ] EGM 047 (Jun 1993): Mortal Kombat
[ ] EGM 048 (Jul 1993): Jungle Strike/Jurassic Park
[ ] EGM 049 (Aug 1993): Aero the Acro-bat
[ ] EGM 050 (Sep 1993): Street Fighter II Turbo vs. Mortal Kombat
[ ] EGM 051 (Oct 1993): Super Street Fighter II
[ ] EGM 052 (Nov 1993): Sonic the Hedgehog 3
[ ] EGM 053 (Dec 1993): Eternal Champions
1994
[ ] EGM 054 (Jan 1994): Mortal Kombat II
[ ] EGM 055 (Feb 1994): NBA Jam
[ ] EGM 056 (Mar 1994): Star Trek: The Next Generation
[ ] EGM 057 (Apr 1994): Beavis & Butt-head
[ ] EGM 058 (May 1994): Fighting Game Spectacular (cover: Super Street Fighter 2 Turbo)
[ ] EGM 059 (Jun 1994): Virtua Fighter
[ ] EGM 060 (Jul 1994): Mortal Kombat II
[ ] EGM 061 (Aug 1994): Super Return of the Jedi
[ ] EGM 062 (Sep 1994): Primal Rage
[ ] EGM 063 (Oct 1994): Donkey Kong Country
[ ] EGM 064 (Nov 1994): Doom
[ ] EGM 065 (Dec 1994): X-Men
1995
[ ] EGM 066 (Jan 1995): Killer Instinct
[ ] EGM 067 (Feb 1995): Mortal Kombat III
[ ] EGM 068 (Mar 1995): Fighting Games
[ ] EGM 069 (Apr 1995): Mortal Kombat 3/Street Fighter Legends
[ ] EGM 070 (May 1995): Mortal Kombat 3
[ ] EGM 071 (Jun 1995): Earthworm Jim 2
[ ] EGM 072 (Jul 1995): Batman Forever
[ ] EGM 073 (Aug 1995): Mortal Kombat 3
[ ] EGM 074 (Sep 1995): Mortal Kombat 3
[ ] EGM 075 (Oct 1995): Fighting Games
[ ] EGM 076 (Nov 1995): Twisted Metal
[ ] EGM 077 (Dec 1995): Alien Trilogy
1996
[ ] EGM 078 (Jan 1996): Ultra 64
[ ] EGM 079 (Feb 1996): Batman Forever
[ ] EGM 080 (Mar 1996): Fighting Games
[ ] EGM 081 (Apr 1996): Street Fighter Alpha 2
[ ] EGM 082 (May 1996): 1996 Preview (cover: Virtua Fighter 3)
[ ] EGM 083 (Jun 1996): 100 Game Previews
[ ] EGM 084 (Jul 1996): N64 Star Wars
[ ] EGM 085 (Aug 1996): Street Fighter Alpha 2
[ ] EGM 086 (Sep 1996): Soviet Strike
[ ] EGM 087 (Oct 1996): Tomb Raider
[ ] EGM 088 (Nov 1996): Twisted Metal 2
[ ] EGM 089 (Dec 1996): Street Fighter III
1997
[ ] EGM 090 (Jan 1997): Mechwarrior 2
[ ] EGM 091 (Feb 1997): Tekken 3
[ ] EGM 092 (Mar 1997): Independence Day
[ ] EGM 093 (Apr 1997): The Lost World: Jurassic Park
[ ] EGM 094 (May 1997): Final Fantasy VII
[ ] EGM 095 (Jun 1997): Crash Bandicoot 2
[ ] EGM 096 (Jul 1997): Fighting Force
[ ] EGM 097 (Aug 1997): Star Wars: Masters of Teras Kasi
[ ] EGM 098 (Sep 1997): Tomb Raider 2
[ ] EGM 099 (Oct 1997): Mortal Kombat 4
[ ] EGM 100 (Nov 1997): 100th Issue
[ ] EGM 101 (Dec 1997): Diddy Kong Racing
1998
[ ] EGM 102 (Jan 1998): Resident Evil 2
[ ] EGM 103 (Feb 1998): 10 Best Multiplayer Games
[ ] EGM 104 (Mar 1998): Yoshi's Story
[ ] EGM 105 (Apr 1998): Tekken 3
[ ] EGM 106 (May 1998): The RPG Revolution (Zelda 64 & Parasite Eve)
[ ] EGM 107 (Jun 1998): Turok 2
[ ] EGM 108 (Jul 1998): Squaresoft Coming to America
[ ] EGM 109 (Aug 1998): Tomb Raider 3
[ ] EGM 110 (Sep 1998): Metal Gear Solid
[ ] EGM 111 (Oct 1998): Star Wars: Rogue Squadron
[ ] EGM 112 (Nov 1998): Sonic Adventure
[ ] EGM 113 (Dec 1998): The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
1999
[ ] EGM 114 (Jan 1999): South Park
[ ] EGM 115 (Feb 1999): Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver
[ ] EGM 116 (Mar 1999): Mario Party
[ ] EGM 117 (Apr 1999): Gamer's Choice Awards
[ ] EGM 118 (May 1999): Star Wars games
[ ] EGM 119 (Jun 1999): Gran Turismo 2
[ ] EGM 120 (Jul 1999): WWF Attitude
[ ] EGM 121 (Aug 1999): Resident Evil games
[ ] EGM 122 (Sep 1999): Dreamcast launch
[ ] EGM 123 (Oct 1999): Spider-Man
[ ] EGM 124 (Nov 1999): The Pokemon Phenomenon
[ ] EGM 125 (Dec 1999): Donkey Kong 64
2000s
2000
[ ] EGM 126 (Jan 2000): Holiday Hardware
[ ] EGM 127 (Feb 2000): Crazy Taxi
[ ] EGM 128 (Mar 2000): Driver 2
[ ] EGM 129 (Apr 2000): Perfect Dark
[ ] EGM 130 (May 2000): Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2
[ ] EGM 131 (Jun 2000): Sega Strikes Back
[ ] EGM 132 (Jul 2000): Final Fantasy IX
[ ] EGM 133 (Aug 2000): Soul Reaver 2
[ ] EGM 134 (Sep 2000): Pokemon
[ ] EGM 135 (Oct 2000): The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask
[ ] EGM 136 (Nov 2000): Playstation 2 launch
[ ] EGM 137 (Dec 2000): Unreal 2 Tournament
2001
[ ] EGM 138 (Jan 2001): Twisted Metal: Black
[ ] EGM 139 (Feb 2001): Xbox
[ ] EGM 140 (Mar 2001): Sonic Team Special
[ ] EGM 141 (Apr 2001): Gran Turismo 3
[ ] EGM 142 (May 2001): Crash Bandicoot
[ ] EGM 143 (Jun 2001): Tony Hawk 3
[ ] EGM 144 (Jul 2001): GBA launch
[ ] EGM 145 (Aug 2001): Gamecube
[ ] EGM 146 (Sep 2001): Final Fantasy X
[ ] EGM 147 (Oct 2001): Metal Gear Solid 2
[ ] EGM 148 (Nov 2001): Gamecube
[ ] EGM 149 (Dec 2001): Xbox vs. Gamecube
2002
[ ] EGM 150 (Jan 2002): Too Many Games!
[ ] EGM 151 (Feb 2002): Final Fantasy X
[ ] EGM 152 (Mar 2002): Maximo: Ghosts to Glory
[ ] EGM 153 (Apr 2002): State of Emergency
[ ] EGM 154 (May 2002): Resident Evil (Gamecube)
[ ] EGM 155 (Jun 2002): SOCOM: US Navy Seals
[ ] EGM 156 (Jul 2002): Stuntman
[ ] EGM 157 (Aug 2002): Nintendo Special Report (3 covers)
[ ] EGM 158 (Sep 2002): Resident Evil?
[ ] EGM 159 (Oct 2002): PS2 Online
[ ] EGM 160 (Nov 2002): Halo 2
[ ] EGM 161 (Dec 2002): Gran Theft Auto: Vice City
2003
[ ] EGM 162 (Jan 2003): Holiday Buyers Guide (55 Best Games)
[ ] EGM 163 (Feb 2003): The Sims
[ ] EGM 164 (Mar 2003): Driver 3
[ ] EGM 165 (Apr 2003): The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker
[ ] EGM 166 (May 2003): Enter the Matrix (2 covers)
[ ] EGM 167 (Jun 2003): Rebel Squadron 3: Rebel Strike
[ ] EGM 168 (Jul 2003): Castlevania Rises on the PS2
[ ] EGM 169 (Aug 2003): Sonic Heroes
[ ] EGM 170 (Sep 2003): Soul Calibur II (3 covers)
[ ] EGM 171 (Oct 2003): SOCOM II
[ ] EGM 172 (Nov 2003): Final Fantasy series (2 covers)
[ ] EGM 173 (Dec 2003): Lord of the Rings (5 covers)
2004
[ ] EGM 174 (Jan 2004): Ultimate Reviews Issue
[ ] EGM 175 (Feb 2004): Top 15 Games of the Millenium
[ ] EGM 176 (Mar 2004): Splinter Cell: Pandora Tomorrow
[ ] EGM 177 (Apr 2004): Getaway 2
[ ] EGM 178 (May 2004): Metal Gear Solid 3
[ ] EGM 179 (Jun 2004): Star Wars: Knight of the Old Republic 2
[ ] EGM 180 (Jul 2004): Driv3r
[ ] EGM 181 (Aug 2004): Sony PSP vs. Nintendo DS
[ ] EGM 182 (Sep 2004): The Lord of the Rings: The Third Age
[ ] EGM 183 (Oct 2004): Scarface
[ ] EGM 184 (Nov 2004): Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
[ ] EGM 185 (Dec 2004): Halo 2 (5 covers, different colored Spartan)
[ ] EGM 186 (Hol 2004): Metal Gear Solid 3
2005
[ ] EGM 187 (Jan 2005): Top Secrets
[ ] EGM 188 (Feb 2005): Year of the Portables (PSP)
[ ] EGM 189 (Mar 2005): The Godfather: The Game
[ ] EGM 190 (Apr 2005): Jade Empire
[ ] EGM 191 (May 2005): Phantasy Star Univers
[ ] EGM 192 (Jun 2005): The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
[ ] EGM 193 (Jul 2005): XBox 360 (variants: system, Perfect Dark Zero)
[ ] EGM 194 (Aug 2005): Console Wars (PS3, XBox, & Revolution/Wii)
[ ] EGM 195 (Sep 2005): Soul Calibur III
[ ] EGM 196 (Oct 2005): Final Fantasy VII compilation
[ ] EGM 197 (Nov 2005): XBox 360 launch guide
[ ] EGM 198 (Dec 2005): Next Gen Updates
2006
[ ] EGM 199 (Jan 2006): The Year in Preview
[ ] EGM 200 (Feb 2006): The Greatest 200 Games of Their Time
[ ] EGM 201 (Mar 2006): Kingdom Hearts II
[ ] EGM 202 (Apr 2006): Rainbow Six: Vegas
[ ] EGM 203 (May 2006): Too Human
[ ] EGM 204 (Jun 2006): Zelda + Revolution (Wii)
[ ] EGM 205 (Jul 2006): Call of Duty 3
[ ] EGM 206 (Aug 2006): Army of Two
[ ] EGM 207 (Sep 2006): Mass Effect
[ ] EGM 208 (Oct 2006): Guitar Hero II
[ ] EGM 209 (Nov 2006): Gears of War
[ ] EGM 210 (Dec 2006): Halo 3
2007
[ ] EGM 211 (Jan 2007): PS3 & Wii
[ ] EGM 212 (Feb 2007): 2007 Best Year Ever
[ ] EGM 213 (Mar 2007): PS3
[ ] EGM 214 (Apr 2007): Rachet & Clank Future
[ ] EGM 215 (May 2007): The Future of Videogames
[ ] EGM 216 (Jun 2007): Tom Clancy's Endwar
[ ] EGM 217 (Jul 2007): Bioshock
[ ] EGM 218 (Aug 2007): Soul Calibur (IV & Legends)
[ ] EGM 219 (Sep 2007): Halo 3
[ ] EGM 220 (Oct 2007): Silent Hill 5
[ ] EGM 221 (Nov 2007): Saints Row 2
[ ] EGM 222 (Dec 2007): Ninja Gaiden 2
[ ] EGM 223 (Hol 2007): Games Overload!
2008
[ ] EGM 224 (Jan 2008): Street Fighter 4
[ ] EGM 225 (Feb 2008): Super Smash Bros. Brawl! (variants: Yoshi, Donkey Kong, Pikachu)
[ ] EGM 226 (Mar 2008): Revenge of the PS3
[ ] EGM 227 (Apr 2008): Grand Theft Auto IV
[ ] EGM 228 (May 2008): SOCOM: Confrontation
[ ] EGM 229 (Jun 2008): 35 Retro Revivals (Splatterhouse 2)
[ ] EGM 230 (Jul 2008): Gears of War 2
[ ] EGM 231 (Aug 2008): Killzone 2
[ ] EGM 232 (Sep 2008): Soul Calibur IV
[ ] EGM 233 (Oct 2008): Mirror's Edge
[ ] EGM 234 (Nov 2008): Resident Evil 5
[ ] EGM 235 (Dec 2008): Watchmen: The End is Nigh
2009
[ ] EGM 236 (Jan 2009): X-Men Origins: Wolverine
Other magazine list threads:
PSM (now PTOM)
Game Informer
GamePro
The above three are ones I did up. A big thanks to Rob2600 for doing the one for Nintendo Power
Nintendo Power