My problem is that I have virtually no idea where to start. Since I play a lot of 2D games, a better d-pad is a must. There was one posted about on Hardcore Gaming 101 that seems pretty good, although the monochrome buttons are throwing me a bit.

Anyone else have any other controller recommendations? I stumbled across this one on Amazon, and it looks pretty good - but the reviews seem to be pretty divided. Anyone have any personal experience with it?