Originally Posted by
Tanooki
The problem here is the problem you said, no history on ebay of the item in such shape. I don't remember it popping up on NintendoAge over the last 4 years I've been registered there and lurking before I didn't pay all that much attention. Usually I think it's fair to say if you have a really nice to amazing complete copy with all the junk still in the box (assuming the 4player part is bagged and tied?) if you had one you really could confirm is brand new it would have to be at least worth twice as much.
Again the problem is, no record of a new one. Because of this you have a problem and that is not knowing. Seeing such things pop up over there the best advice I could give you they probably would too short of someone wanting it and trying to get a deal -- throw it up on ebay with a value perhaps triple what the sold used/great copy went for with a BEST OFFER option and take no less than double ($600) unless you get fed up with sitting on it. I hate giving advice like this as it nauseates me how much some people have driven games into being a commodity market, but that is the best way to play the angle. Let it ride, set a high OBO offer on ebay, let the offers ride and rack up, and take whatever you're comfy with, because in the end it will be whatever that guy is willing to pay which could be $50 over the used one or $500 over the used one...it's a gamble.