What are some games that receive very high scores or you hear lots of people say is an awesome game but you never saw the appeal?

For me the first that comes to mind is Resident Evil 4. I liked 1, 2, and Code Veronica. Thats it.

Grand Theft Auto 4. Didnt like it at all. In fact its one of the worst games I have ever played and thats not hyperbole.

Star Wars KOTOR. I just didnt get it. Too many menus, combat system was weird.

Flashback. I just didnt like the controls. It got great reviews back in the day.

Marvel VS Capcom. Just couldnt get into it