I don't just mean underrated games or guilty pleasures. What I mean here is games that everyone else classifies as pure horsedung, but you play a lot and you can't see why they badmouth it. One that I think fits here is Ehrgeiz. I've heard many mixed reviews for this game, but the majority of those that I have seen seem to classify it as mediocre. Personally, I think Ehrgeiz rocks! It just has so much depth, a pretty good fighting system, and six characters from FFVII is a nice bonus. The adventure mode is the best part, IMO. Beating that certainly took a load out of my life. Ehrgeiz is the best example that I can muster, but I think everyone out there has some more fitting games. Anyone?