I ordered a half dozen previously rented games from Gamefly last week, after signing up for a free trial membership I heard about on CheapAssGamer. Thought I'd relate my experience in case anyone else was considering doing this. It includes free shipping, with new boxes and manuals. For about $75 dollars, I ordered the following titles:
PS2
Bujingai: The Forsaken City
Pinball Hall of Fame
Onimusha 3: Demon Siege
Xbox
Battlestar Galactica
The Guy Game
GC
Wario Ware Inc: Mega Party Games
They came in today, all in individual bubble mailers oddly enough. The boxes and manuals were mint as promised, and the games had very light scratches and fingerprints if any at all. I don't anticipate any problems booting them up, but if I do, I'll report back.
I'm pretty impressed by the condition of the games, given their prices and am thinking about ordering more. Seems like a good outfit to me...I'll be cancelling my membership before the trial ends though...not much of a game renter.
Rich