MUST be in Near Mint to Mint, CIB.
Legend of Zelda - $40, up to 2
Contra - $40, up to 2
Mike Tyson's Punch Out!! - $25 up to 2
Near Mint to Mint means to me:
Game - no scratches, writing, lifting labels, scuff marks.
Box - no missing tabs, no creases, no fading, no noticeable wear. It could just as easily be sitting on the shelf in 1987.
Booklet - no missing pages, no creased corners, no wear on booklet binding or corners.
If it a true gem, I have no problem paying a higher premium.