Ok, so I sold some old Magic The Gather cards I had lying around online. A couple of them sold to the same bidder for around $45.00.
Unfortunately, I did not offer insurance in the auction (an oversight by me) but it does state no insurance is offered. They shipped via regular lettermail, so tracking wasn't even an option.
A week after they've sent I get an email asking why they haven't shown up even though it's been three week (despite the fact it's actually been under two weeks). I told them when they shipped and never heard a reply.
Today (around three weeks since sale) I get a Paypal email stating that he opened a dispute.
Since he never bothered to email before opening one, I decided to take a look at his feedback. Dispute his high positive feedback I can find a good 10-20 references that he claims things have never arrived within the past six months.
So, my guess is he actually got them but I have no way to prove it.
Is there any possible way I can win this and not lose my money?