I never said it was a bad trade if it was I wouldn't have made it but it was teetering in my mind. It's more that most people I know wouldn't trade a PS3 for random PS2 and GC games but it was just setting on my floor depreciating now if these depreciate I can at least get enjoyment from playing them. Also Craigslist has lots of listings for PS3s under $180 and we put mine at $250.
mobiusclimber that's almost verbatim with what we decided so I feel better about this trade thanks all.