Are you serious? There is nothing in his description that claims he has owned them from the beginning. All it says is that the items are coming from a non-smoking collector's home prior to being shipped out. As long as he is non-smoking and a collector, his description is accurate. Look, I don't like this guy either and I hope nobody buys from him, but I really think his auctions intentionally or not make a strong statement against the foolishness of VGA grading.