I didn't watch the show, but I don't think the final results are TOO bad. There are a few games noticeably missing, and a few categories that are just plain silly, but I think some of 2004's great games got recognized.
Not until the 2004 Otto Awards are final, however, can the REAL winners stand up and be proud. Sorry, no trophy though.
Game of the Year: San Andreas
Best Game Based on a Movie: Chronicles of Riddick
Best Performance by a Human Female: Brooke Burke - NFSU2
Best Performance by a Human Male: Sam Jackson - San Andreas
Cyber Vixen of the Year: BloodRayne
Best Driving Game: Burnout 3
Best Action Game: San Andreas
Best Sports Game: Madden 2005
Best Soundtrack: San Andreas
Best Fighting Game: MK: Deception
Designer of the Year: Jason Jones - Bungie
Best First Person Action: Halo 2
Best PC Game: Half Life 2
Best Wireless Game: Might and Magic
Best Graphics: Half Life 2
Best New Technology: Nintendo DS
Best Handheld Game: Metroid: Zero Mission
Best Mass Multiplayer Game: City of Heroes
Best RPG: Fable
Best Military Game: CoD: Finest Hour
Best Song in a Game: American Idiot - Green Day - Madden 2005
Best Gaming Publication: Game Informer
Best Gaming Website: Gamespot
Most Addictive Game: Burnout 3