Hmmm... Mr. Do! would be my favorite. Perhaps not entirely food-based, but since foodstuffs play such an integral role in play mechanics (cherries for score and level completion, apples to kill enemies, treats to stop the action and get EXTRA lives), I think that would be the best.
Otherwise, Pressure Cooker, Fast Food, Burgertime, Food Fight, (BUDWEISER!) Tapper, hell it's hard to find a food based game that ISN'T good.
Except for Peter Pepper's Ice Cream Factory. Yuck!