#55: Star Trek: Judgment Rites CD-ROM (PC)
Excellent writing with a decreased/eliminated focus on ship combat, but the puzzle design was fairly difficult overall (much more so than the first game). While the graphics have been improved in general (backgrounds now occupy the entire size of the screen instead of just portions of it, animations are more varied and smoother, and there's generally more detail throughout), it does get kind of annoying when they try to shift the perspective of the background to an isometric viewpoint while using the same sprites as normal. There's a few instances of this in the game and gives a brief impression of being a bit...amateur.
Tons of spoken dialog (which actually inflated the size of the game to twice that of 25th Anniversary), though the audio quality is a bit lacking once again. The game just came out a few years before MP3 made its presence known, sadly Actually, the game itself is fairly text-heavy (especially in comparison to 25th Anniversary), so the episodic design is for the best as you can cap off an episode, take a break for a day or so, and come back and hammer away at another one.
In addition to the increased amount of spoken text, there's some prerendered video in there, too. It's not all over the place, but it is prevalent early on when the ship explodes and whenever you enter/exit orbit with another planet. While it cleans things up a bit, I do prefer the previous graphical style in most cases (except in the beginning when the ship exploded...that shit was awesome).
You get to use more than just Dr. McCoy and Mr. Spock on the away team, too! While you won't get any red shirts to kill, you'll get to play around with Chekov, Uhura, and Scotty on various away team missions. Additionally, Dr. McCoy's role has been increased significantly, so expect to be using that medical tricorder a hell of a lot more often
Overall, I'd probably give it the nod over 25th Anniversary. The improvements in the game design outweigh the increased adventure difficulty and at times wonky art design.