I vote for the Sega Saturn gamepad, cause its best for fighting games and is VERY comfortable.
While I love the SNES gamepad, the Saturn is the most comfortable.
TurboSage
PS: I searched for a thread that asked this question, and I couldn't find one.. I hope I didn't miss it.. Please don't throw cabbage at me for starting a thread.......
(I hope I didn't miss any huge ones in the poll......)