Originally Posted by
mobiusclimber
You keep waffling back and forth between saying two things: 1) you're answering the OPs question of whether he'd be able to make his money back if he kept those two carts; and 2) what YOU would do and how much YOU'D sell it for and what YOU'D keep. These two things are at odds. When you brought up point #1, I quoted that and stated that if OP did what he said he was going to do (keep the carts ONLY, not the boxes), then those two boxes would bring in at least $150. Which is why I was so incredulous when your next statement was "If you're going to be keeping those 2 games and want to break even by selling the rest, you'd have to get everything for around $200 or less. I doubt there's any way to break even at the seller's asking price unless you'd sell off those games too." How is it that if he sells the boxes for those two games + the rest of the CIB stuff, he wouldn't be able to make more than $200 on everything? This is the question I had with your assertion, but you keep going back to what YOU would do, not what the OP would do (and misunderstanding my point that the rest of the stuff would sell easily for well over $50). BTW, next time you get some CIB Zeldas and Punch-Outs, I'll gladly pay $10 and shipping for em!