Let the definition debate begin.
I know that you address carlcarlson, and, honestly, I don't mean it in a belittling way at all. Actually, I like discussions about genre definitions because most of them are antiquated.
However, you know that we are then in a discussion about a definition of a RPG, and that will be lenghty, and I'm afraid we will sacrifice the inclusionary character of the list on the altar of consistency based on an (all-agreed?) definition.
Dangerous, dangerous...
but I don't try to discourage such a discussion at all.
Here is my question about a specific case and I don't know if the game should be included.
Sudo suggested Too Human. After reading reviews, I'm still on the edge on this one. I'd tend to put it in a borderline category.