Animal Crossing I'd definitely agree with.

Fatal frame, I was gonna say, but that game is too flawed for my liking, I haven't finished it because 2 ghosts attacked me in the fish tank room and I am completely UNABLE to beat them, no stone mirrors, little health kits, can't even kill ONE of them. friggin STUPID.

Devil may cry - I could never understand the liking of this game... maybe I bought it too long after it's release?

Ikaruga - Cookie cutter shooting game. YES, it's a GREAT shooting game, the best ever imo, and while the black/white was innovative, I suppose it COULD fit up here, but the rest of the game was so generic (not that it was generic standalone, but you can't really change/improve much on SHmups.)

Metroid Prime - Agree with ya on this one, 2-d to 3-d translation at it's best. Now if they could only do Kid Icarus, Ice Climbers, and the 30 other NES games that have been neglected....