Quote Originally Posted by Niku-Sama View Post
if it isn't perfect than what would be?
A controller with the build quality of the Hori, perhaps slightly larger for American hands, d-pad and analog stick equally accessible by the left thumb as seen with subsequent attempts like the Dual Shock, built-in rumble capabilities, and wireless using modern methods such as BlueTooth.

Sadly, such a thing doesn't exist, making the Hori the best option.