You like it when a game is like a cartoon, a book, a comic, a fairy tale where there's imagination, uniqueness to the look and feel, where you have to use your mind some to fill in the blanks as old games or those faking being old now don't do on their own. When they cross into some extreme level of closer to reality, or at least a movie theater level presentation of reality, you get detracted from it and the imagination is gone as it filled in all that and kind of blends together like yearly hollywood summer/holiday blockbusters. That about it? If so I do agree quite a bit. You really had to take an old 8/16bit style of game and fill in the imagination gaps, but with a game even as amazing as Uncharted series, Witcher, etc the void is done, it's like sitting in on an Indiana Jones or some Maleficent like motion picture. Also secondarily the modern style of game in that reality comes so close to potential life the wonder is pulled away from it perhaps. And lastly of course you have the obvious issue of creeping up eventually on that whole uncanny valley concept of too close it gets creepy or uncomfortable for many people.