I'd completely forgotten I had even done this, but reading Anthony1's power rankings reminded me...and so I figured I'd share it.
In January of '04, I went to around 50 different gaming message boards (oddly, I don't think this was one of them) and had people submit their best 20 or so games of all time. I got a pretty good response, and was able to make a top 250 list. I wasn't able to avoid a good amount of fanboyism and bias, but I think the list turned out alright. If the situation were right, I wouldn't be opposed to taking this on again at some point, perhaps with just the people here. As for the results...
Here's a visual list (definite 56k warning here). I made all the images myself over the course of a few days:
http://aiuax.com/greatestgames/
And if that doesn't work for some reason (of if you want more info), here's an explanation of how it was put together, as well as a text only version of the final list:
http://www.livejournal.com/users/cla...nut/57946.html