The one and only Cmtz had a dream about the Nintendo Revolution. I had the controller in my hands and it worked so natural. It reminded me of the time I first played Mario Bros for the Nintendo and wanted to jump, I would move my controller in an upward motion and look stupid. My point is this will work since our first instincts when we started playing were to move the controller, but later we were forced not to do that. Now with the introduction of the Revolution everything will be as it should have been.
Incase you want to make your own controller and try the button lay out.