Gamestop sucks, that's a given. Catch is, you accepted it as being an open copy the moment you paid for it. If it was the only copy and you were given an empty case, then you'd be cheated. Add insult to injury if you didnt realize it till you get in your car and return less then 5 minutes later and they swear they gave you the game and somehow they have a disc only copy when 5 minutes before they only had the one. Yet you didnt leave the parking space right in front of the store and not one customer walked in.