Max Payne Xbox version or PS2 version

[roushimsx]

I recall the Grand Theft Auto games playing a bit better on the PS2. The Xbox ones were much better in pretty much every way other than control (mainly due to placement of the white/black buttons). Can't think of anything else other than what's been mentioned.

One thing I love about the xbox versions of games is the save times. Holy hell were those a breath of fresh air compared to the slow-as-molasses PS2 memory card save times. Thank god games like Ratchet & Clank found ways to hide them.

Did the port of Max Payne 2 clean things up at all or did it follow in line with the first (near unplayable) Max Payne?

[TheDomesticInstitution]

I recall the Grand Theft Auto games playing a bit better on the PS2. The Xbox ones were much better in pretty much every way other than control (mainly due to placement of the white/black buttons). Can't think of anything else other than what's been mentioned.

God, was there a learning curve for the Harrier-type jet. Getting gold medals in some of the driving/flying courses is near impossible- for me anyway. But yeah the black/white buttons are out of the way, and it's a bitch when essential gameplay functions are mapped to them.

[BHvrd]

I recall the Grand Theft Auto games playing a bit better on the PS2. The Xbox ones were much better in pretty much every way other than control (mainly due to placement of the white/black buttons).

There were also audio problems with the Xbox GTA ports. The ambience such as car sounds and pedestrians would cut out and not come back on. Other than that it looked better on Xbox and had custom soundtracks, but I prefer the PS2 versions of those, they seem more complete on a whole.

Max Payne was/is indeed quite a bit better on Xbox though, controls and looks much better. In this case definetely get the Xbox version. PS2 version is pretty messy in comparison.

[Neil Koch]

Hm, I prefer the Xbox versions of the GTA games. The custom soundtracks - especially the feature in SA where you can have your whole MP3 library play like a station - add a lot to the games IMO. And the games visually stand up a lot better on the Xbox versions to my eyes.

Though I do agree that doing drive-bys is much easier in the PS2 games.

[The 1 2 P]

While I love Max Payne, I haven't played the PS2 version. But like others have said, most cross platform games looked and generally played better on the Xbox because of the added hardware muscle. Having said that, I remember reading somewhere that the PS2 version of Burnout 3 had "spark effects"(when two cars are grinding) that were absent from the Xbox version. I'm not sure if thats true but I do know that the Xbox version ran at a smooth 60 fps.

[exit]

I would say play them on a PC since it will be a better experience overall. I remember making the mistake of buying Max Payne 2 for PS2 because it was rather cheap and while I did enjoy the hell out of it, there were plenty of glitches and bugs that had me yelling at my TV.

[BHvrd]

While I love Max Payne, I haven't played the PS2 version. But like others have said, most cross platform games looked and generally played better on the Xbox because of the added hardware muscle. Having said that, I remember reading somewhere that the PS2 version of Burnout 3 had "spark effects"(when two cars are grinding) that were absent from the Xbox version. I'm not sure if thats true but I do know that the Xbox version ran at a smooth 60 fps.

You know I remember hearing that too, never checked into it but I do know for a fact that Need For Speed 2: Hot Pursuit is much better on the PS2!

It was so much more slow, clunky and graphically inferior on both Xbox and Gamecube believe it or not. There are for sure better versions of some games on PS2 compared to ports to other systems, but Max Payne ain't one of 'em.

[garagesaleking!!]

everyone loves xbox, thats why it still puzzles me that xbox in its day did not do as well as the ps2, in my opinion it should of ousted the ps2, the ps2 has never really impressed me, i prefer xbox controllers, and a hd compared to memory cards, seems like a no brainer to me.

[swlovinist]

An easy answer garagesaleking!! is that the Xbox was discontinued early, was not really discounted too much, and did not nearly have the third party support(or RPGS in volume) that the PS2 has(as in present tense). With that being said the great library that it did have, it did demonstrate to be an excellent first console from Microsoft.