Technically the winner isn't even on the list. However I voted for MGS3S for the PS3.

Sarcasm because the game is actually on the PS2.

Anyways. MGS3S, just like every other MGS has crappy gameplay where you have to wait three hours and 37 minutes before you can advance forward to the next screen. Not only that but they add the amazing part where you have to walk 17 days straight through the river of sorrow because you killed 4,537,032.4 enemies to get to the end just so you can revive yourself.

However. One good thing about MGS3 and MGS3S. The storyline. The entire reason I played through that crappy game is because it had one of the best storylines ever in a video game. I don't give a crap about Metal Gear and I loved the storyline. Ocelot was my favorite character though he's a favorite of most peoples(not sure if he was as awesome in the first game.)

So yeah. I actually only played up to the first boss on the first game(which was actually Ocelot where he got his arm cut off.) I really didn't like it. I played halfway through the second to where I killed the one woman, and I hated that one and all of Raiden's bitching like a little pussy girl every two seconds. Then I forced myself to play MGS3 just to finish the story which was well worth it. The bonus to watch the videos over again and blooper videos were nice as well.