Here be another one for the Classic Computing forum.

Quote Originally Posted by InsaneDavid View Post
Mystery Game #1 - In this game you were in an alchemy lab using various ingredients to make monsters. That's all I remember.
So I was just reading this thread which led me to this page of reviews which identifies the game in question as the incredibly generic-sounding The Incredible Laboratory.

Now to delve into what other secrets may dwell under the flag of Sunburst Communications!