How is this even a discussion? Goldeneye wins beyond a shadow of a doubt in all of these polls.

I remember playing it and being "wowed" by the AI at the time. Guards would actually come to your location if you shot an automatic without a silencer! Guards would occasionally pull out grenades and chuck them your way (and not overdue it every other second like in Halo).

Graphics have indeed aged but that was the pinnacle of my gaming day. Tons of replay value in the multiplayer, and tons of replay value in missons with target times. You'd be the envy of the kids in the neighborhood if you could get all of the cheats unlocked yourself (which I was quite proud to do).