Geez. Seriously? You act as if we don't have the ability to examine the condition of the games in person. About a third of the games I buy there are in brand new condition.
I could care less about gutted new titles -- people are crazier to be paying fifty bucks for games that will sell for half that a few months later. And if you planned on opening it anyways to play, what difference does it really make? fucking ocd types.