
Originally Posted by
Satoshi_Matrix
I know most roms are illegal. I know that those same roms are available in some cases through the various official online stores. But I just honestly don't care. It's almost always a victimless 'crime' if you can call it that.
These games made their money back when they were new. Many of the developers don't exist anymore, rights holders are different, and unlike pirating a modern game, you aren't taking money away from people who are actively making their living through retro game roms. If I buy a copy of Super Mario Bros. through the Virtual Console, the only place that money goes to is to Nintendo directly, not to anyone who worked on the game. And even if that were the case, they don't need that money, and I feel well justified in downloading the rom because over the years I've bought at least five official copies of the game through various means, the last time on the GameBoy Advance.
I take a very different stance against piracy of anything that is current, but once something is ~10 years old? Piracy doesn't hurt anyone because you aren't taking money away from anyone but third party sellers such as guys on ebay who aren't affiliated with the original developers/publishers in the first place. I've built up a massive retro game collection not because I set out to do so, but because I bought games when they were new, and over time kept them until they could be considered retro. Nearly my entire N64, PS1, GBC, GBA, GameCube, PS2 and Xbox libraries are made up of games that I bought brand new. Hundreds of games. I feel fully justified to pirate whatever I want on any of those platforms. Maybe it is wrong, but it ultimately doesn't impact anyone.